How to Personalize with a Cookie Stamp

It’s the perfect touch for your mishloach manos. Making cookies with a cookie stamp allows you to personalize a message and add an edible item all at once.

Did you ever use a cookie stamp? Once you see how fun it is to personalize your sugar cookies, you might not need any other cookie cutters in your baking bin. It’s just what you need for your mishloach manos. It’s classy for your own packages. It’s cute for your kids. It’s low-cost, edible, and adds that perfect, personal touch you were looking for.

You might just find yourself using your cookie stamp all year long for all occasions, not only before Purim!

To start, you’ll need a great sugar cookie recipe. We have one here. This sugar cookie dough has been on Between Carpools since 2016. It’s a classic sugar cookie that’s tried-and-true that we’ve been turning to for a decade! Note that the recipe is very large. You can halve it, but you might need the whole thing if you’re making a lot of cookies. When it comes to sugar cookies that come out consistent and neat, we do recommend sticking with a classic margarine-based dough like this one vs. an oil-based dough.

As far as the cookie stamp itself, it’s easy to use! The stamps come with letters; simply slide them into the cookie cutter to personalize your message.

Just because you’re using a stamp doesn’t mean your cookie shape needs to be generic. If you want to use a shape that fits your theme, you can also stamp cookies of other shapes with a message using embossing sets like this one.

Once your stamp is set up, simply press it into the dough like you would with any cookie cutter.

The stamp creates a message that’s clearly legible and remains so through the baking process.

Your cookie can simply say Happy Purim or include your family name. For the most crisp details, dip your cutter in flour before pressing!

This dough keeps its shape well even without refrigeration.

Your cookies are ready for wrapping!

You can take your personalized cookies a step further with these custom face-shaped cookies. Everyone will definitely know who this mishloach manos came from!

Whether it’s the whole family or just one of your children. There are few things that are more adorable!

Voila! Aren’t these fun??

Adding a themed cookie shape to your Purim theme also ties everything together. In this post you will find amazing theme ideas and packaging to go with it all. Almost all the themes will have a cookie cutter shape in them.

See another way we used cookie cutter stampers in this post.

Message in a Cookie

Three Shape Cutters

Personalized Cookie Cutter

Send your picture to service@pupbusiness.com with your order number. Their team will draft your picture for approval.

Personalized Cookie Stamp

This one lets your include your message on the perimeter of the cookie. It includes interchangeable letters, numbers, and symbols.

This looks fun!

Custom Name

How about this one for a truly unique cookie cutter!

Cookie Embossing Set

This lets you add a message when you want to use a cookie cutter of a different shape. The letters are small, so you’ll be able to fit a nice message.

Purim Themed Cookie Cutters

Adding a themed cookie shape to your Purim theme also ties everything together. In this post you will find amazing theme ideas and packaging to go with it all. Almost all the themes will have a cookie cutter shape in them.

Spiral Swirl

If you’re not looking to personalize, you can still have fun with cookie cutters with unique, fun  shapes like this one to add that custom touch.

Between Carpools

Between Carpools is a collaboration between five talented friends who like to get a lot of stuff done “between carpools.” Since 2016, we’ve been sharing home and organizing tips, parenting insights, activities, how-to’s and DIYs, and of course, entertaining ideas, recipes, and inspiring reads both on the site and app.

9 responses to “How to Personalize with a Cookie Stamp”

  1. M Avatar
    M

    Any cutters with Hebrew letterings?

  2. Riki Avatar
    Riki

    How adorable! I’d love to see a post on the best ways to frost cookies…icing vs fondant etc

    Thanks!

  3. Tova Avatar
    Tova

    We made a personalized name stamp with a 3D printer and stamped onto fondant. It was actually so easy and came out great!

  4. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    What’s the Halacha on Shabbos for eating a personalized cookie directly on the cookie? I would love to make these for a kiddush .

  5. estyh Avatar
    estyh

    when i want to order the custom face cutter i didn’t see where to put in a picture of the faces,

  6. Fraidy Penfil Avatar
    Fraidy Penfil

    HiI woiuld recomend that people ask a Rav about using the Custom Face Cookie Cutter because it may be a shaila of creating a graven image.

  7. Suri Avatar
    Suri

    The message in a cookie set linked above is only arriving March 1st or later. Do you have another such item you can recommend instead?

  8. L Avatar
    L

    Thanks, I made these for Shalach Manos this year, it came out gorgeous!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!