Honey Mustard Turkey London Broil

If you’ve never tried cooking a boneless, skinless turkey breast, also sometimes called Turkey London Broil, you’re about to discover a new wholesome, family-friendly favorite.

Before we get to the evolvement of this cooking technique, I need to tell you why you should try Turkey London Broil (a whole, boneless skinless half turkey breast) if you haven’t yet.

First, if your family loves chicken cutlets, then there’s no reason they’ll love this too.

Plus, it’s super economical. You get a lot of food for the money. 

Third, most of us already enjoy turkey cold cuts, especially the kids. It’s that lean protein that we’re so relieved that they eat (at least they get that protein in!). The hot, freshly baked version of turkey breast is even better than the cold cuts. 

We love it fresh, hot, and sliced on a sandwich with pickles and cole slaw. 

I was first introduced to Turkey London Broil by Renee Muller back in the day. She originally cooked it by searing it in a really hot pan before baking in the oven until it’s cooked through. 

But since then, we’ve gotten a little smarter (or lazier?) and learned how not to use pots when we don’t need to. 

First, let’s season the turkey. 

We’re keeping it simple with some salt and pepper, and then a honey mustard rub. 

After all, honey turkey is our family’s favorite version of cold cuts, so why not just go with that?

Use a gloved hand to rub the mixture all over the turkey breast.

Instead of searing in a pan, we’ve long since learned that broiling also does a great job of searing a piece of meat, so we’re going to broil the turkey first to get that crust. Keep it short; 5-6 minutes per side is just right.

Then, heat the oven to 350⁰F. Cover the turkey with aluminum foil and bake for 40-45 minutes. 

Let rest for a few minutes before slicing. 

The sliced turkey is delicious on a sandwich with cole slaw and pickles. It’s also delicious on top of a salad with greens, cabbage, and Caesar dressing. 

Turkey London Broil

2 (1.5-2 lb) Turkey London Broil (skinless, boneless half turkey breast)

Salt, for sprinkling

Black pepper, for sprinkling

2 Tbsp honey

2 Tbsp Dijon mustard

1 Tbsp olive oil

  1. Place turkey breasts in a 9 x 13-inch baking pan. Season with salt and pepper. 
  2. In a small bowl, combine honey, mustard, and oil. Using gloved hands, rub into turkey breasts. This can be done up to 24 hours ahead (keep covered in the refrigerator if not cooking immediately).
  3. Set a rack on the top third of the oven. Add baking pans with turkey and broil for 5-6 minutes per side (if there’s no room for both turkey breasts under the broiler, they may need to take turns). 
  4. Heat oven to 350⁰F. Cover turkey with aluminum foil and bake for 40-45 minutes. 
  5. Let rest for 10 minutes before slicing. Enjoy in a sandwich or on top of a salad with cole slaw and pickles.

FOR EXCLUSIVE CONTENT AND A PEEK BEHIND THE SCENES, MAKE SURE TO JOIN OUR WHATSAPP STATUS HERE. JOIN OUR WHATSAPP GROUP AND WE’LL LET YOU KNOW WHEN A NEW POST IS UP!

Victoria Dwek Avatar

Victoria Dwek

Victoria is the best-selling author of nine kosher cookbooks and a popular columnist for Ami Magazine. She always has the words for bringing everything that’s in our hearts onto the page. 

12 responses to “Honey Mustard Turkey London Broil”

  1. Mrs. S Avatar

    Thank you so much! This sounds delish! What would you suggest to season with if I want to avoid sugar?

    1. Renee Muller Avatar
      Renee Muller

      Just stick to some salt and it should be just fine. The sugar acts as a rub and kind of creates a caramelized crust that seals in the juices. Its a minimal amount of sugar but you can definitely avoid it if you like. It just might result in a drier piece of meat

  2. D Avatar

    How about a recipe for a whole turkey? My husband’s work place gives out a whole turkey every year and I never know what to do with it.

    1. Renee Muller Avatar
      Renee Muller

      Absolutely. Perhaps next year come this time of year!

  3. Ariella Avatar
    Ariella

    What should we do if we do not have an oven safe grill pan?

    1. Renee Muller Avatar
      Renee Muller

      simply transfer to a baking pan

  4. H Avatar
    H

    Will this work for a Shabbos lunch main, for those rare families that don’t like chulent?

    1. Renee Muller Avatar
      Renee Muller

      Absolutely! thats exactly when I like to serve it! serves well cold

  5. Michelle Avatar
    Michelle

    I made this tonite, using your recipe. It was absolutely fabulous.

  6. five nights at freddy's Avatar

    I didn’t think this was ever a debate because in my family we have turkey and ham for thanksgiving. I assumed it was similar for most people but I guess not

    1. Chaviva Avatar
      Chaviva

      Ham is not kosher

  7. Simone Shuman Avatar
    Simone Shuman

    maybe this is a dumb Q – but I am using the grill pan twice right? Once I am using it on the stovetop, then I cover the dirty top with foil, put the turkey back on and put the whole thing in the oven?

    I have a flat Le Creuset Round Bistro Grill… which is oven safe but it is also going to be quite hot just to move into the oven. Am I missing something?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!