Glazed squares of chocolate cake on a white platter.

The Perfect Brownie. Or Chocolate Cake Square. 

How to glaze brownies or chocolate cake to perfection. Because, it’s all about the glaze.

Every recipe has a story, right? Well, it turns out, so does every hack. 

And here it is. 

I once invited my sister over for Shabbos. I told her to take the week off and not bring a thing which, of course, she ignored and showed up with 3 different cakes and a salad and also a dessert. Anyway, I have to admit that I do like when people bring stuff because that’s the only way that I get to try new things, you know? I was so bored of my Shabbos cake, and here instead were these gorgeous glazed brownies which were devoured by all. 

You know how, when you slice a glazed cake, it’s impossible not to get those bumpy edges, not to mention, crumbs all over the place? Well, these squares were so cute and so perfect. They were so perfect that they looked pretty enough to serve on a platter. Even pretty enough to send for a kiddush!

I also liked the fact that it was easy for the little ones to help themselves without making an enormous mess. 

So, what’s the secret? How do you glaze a sheet pan cake in a way that it cuts into perfect squares? The answer might surprise you. 

You slice it up first, and glaze it after. 

But hey, it makes so much sense. 

But, let’s start from the beginning. 

Why bake into a sheet pan? It’s the best way to achieve a maximum amount of pieces at minimum effort. We figured out that two boxes of Duncan Hines Dark Chocolate Fudge Cake Mix fit perfectly in this half sheet pan. Make sure to line it with a piece of parchment first.  Or make this brownie recipe from scratch.

I baked the cake for 1 hour and 5-10 minutes until a toothpick at the center came out dry with just a few crumbs. 

Once cooled, I popped the cake into the freezer for about 2 hours. That helped with cutting it with minimal crumbling. I once left it in the freezer overnight and, as a result, it was much harder to slice. I needed to wait for it to thaw first. You want it firm and semi frozen, so that it slices easily but without too much effort. 

Use a large knife like this one here and make sure to cut all the way down. All. The. Way. 

Also, cut it into smaller squares. It’s the perfect amount. 

I generally will do rows of 12 x 6 squares. Cut out the outer edges into a neat square.     

Now for the glaze (see recipe below)

I like this glaze because you mix it in a pot, and you can do that part in advance. Just heat it up a bit once you are ready to glaze the cake.

Pour the glaze over the cake all at once.

Use an offset spatula to spread the glaze evenly all over the cake.

Remove the outer layer, the “frame”. With the help of a fork, lift each piece of cake individually UP and then away and place it on a platter or a pan, for freezing.

The secret to achieving nice, perfect pieces of cake is to take your time when removing each piece, doing it slowly and carefully. The results are worth it!

This cake/brownie freezes really well and yields A LOT of pieces (about 72). So it’s perfect for sending to a simcha or, to stock up your freezer. It’s really nice to have 4-5 pans of cut cake to pull out one each Shabbos morning! 

Glazed squares of chocolate cake on a white platter.
Print Recipe
5 from 3 votes

Chocolate Glaze

Ingredients

  • cups confectioners sugar
  • ¼ cup water
  • ¼ cup + 1 tbsp oil
  • 3 tbsp cocoa powder 

Instructions

  • Mix all ingredients in a small pot, over medium heat. Use a whisk to mix until combined and smooth. (You can do this part in advance. Just heat it up a bit once you are ready to glaze the cake.)
  • Pour over the cake while still warm but not hot. Use an offset spatula to spread over the cooled cake.

Notes

1 recipe is enough to cover a half sheet pan of cake.
header between carpools logo

Renee Muller

Renee is a sought-after food and lifestyle stylist and the author of two cookbooks. With dishes and linens as her paint palette, it’s her artistry that weaves a beautiful story in the photos on this site.

22 responses to “The Perfect Brownie. Or Chocolate Cake Square. ”

  1. Michelle Schwartz Avatar
    Michelle Schwartz

    Can these be frozen after they are glazed and still look beautiful?

  2. sarah Avatar
    sarah

    can you link a good moist chocolate cake to use, for those of us who don’t use the OU hechsher?

    1. Shoshana Gifter Avatar
      Shoshana Gifter

      Best chocolate cake ever is the Hershey’s cake from their website.
      https://www.hersheyland.com/recipes/hersheys-perfectly-chocolate-chocolate-cake.html

      1. Mindy Avatar
        Mindy

        That does look good, I wonder if it’s the texture and denseness needed for this recipe to get those pretty squares

  3. Rivky Avatar
    Rivky

    Yes please post a good moist choc cake in a cookie sheet thanks

  4. Mindy Avatar
    Mindy

    Was just coming here to ask for a good recipe for such a cake! Please?????

  5. Chana Avatar
    Chana

    This looks great. Like another poster asked, can you freeze this once the cake has been glazed?

  6. Sarah Rose Avatar
    Sarah Rose

    I don’t have a half sheet pan. How many boxes do I need for a cookie sheet?

    1. Between Carpools Avatar

      I would stick with the same amount. “Two boxes of Duncan Hines Dark Chocolate Fudge Cake Mix fit perfectly in this half sheet pan”
      The difference in size, cookie sheet to half sheet, is just a couple inches…

      1. Mindy Avatar
        Mindy

        Please – a recipe that would work similarly to the cake mix, for those who dont use that hechsher or dont like all the chemicals in the mixes. Thank you!!!!

      2. Sury Avatar
        Sury

        5 stars
        Made this for Shabbos and I’m not saying how many I already ate!!
        They are heaven! Thank you!

  7. sara Avatar
    sara

    Nothing stopping you using your own brownie or chocolate cake recipes it’s just to get ideas

    1. Mindy Avatar
      Mindy

      Yes but I would think a specific density/level of fluffiness is needed here to get the pieces to cut so nicely. It’s a ton of patchkediky work for it to not come out right.

  8. B. H. Avatar
    B. H.

    Thanks for great tip!!!
    You suggest freezing cake first, but then glazing cake when still warm. How does that work? Thanks.

    1. Mindy Avatar
      Mindy

      That’s a good point. What are you supposed to do?

    2. Y Avatar
      Y

      I think they mean while the glaze is still warm. Pour warm glaze over the cool cake.

  9. Rachel deutsch Avatar
    Rachel deutsch

    5 stars
    To avoid bubbles forming in the glaze: add only part of the liquid ingredients first forming a paste. Then slowly incorporate the rest of the liquid. Enjoy!

  10. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    Is the word dessert supposed to be a link to a specific recipe? Cuz it doesn’t have work

  11. ET Avatar
    ET

    I followed the two Duncan Hines cake way, but it was fully baked after 40 min. I think an 1 and 5 minutes would be very dry.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!