What’s even more incredible is that these peanut butter cups are pareve (non-dairy; vegan).
I’ve tried to make a copycat of Reese’s peanut butter cups before, trying lots of different recipes from all over, but none of them came out the way I imagined they should be. Whether the filling wasn’t tasty or creamy enough or the chocolate was just too hard (as melted chocolate always is when it sets), none of the other recipes which claimed to be like Reese’s were ever even close.
It’s all to my son’s credit that I was even challenged to try again.
Earlier this year, I was preparing desserts for his bar mitzvah. I had made some mini peanut butter cups as a garnish for a peanut butter dessert. That’s all they were, a garnish. But I had plenty so I gave my kids some to taste.
“You can do better mom,” he told me, “Don’t use these. Try again.”
“But it’s just a garnish. It’s peanut butter and melted chocolate. What can be wrong?”
“Trust me, Mom. You can do better than this.”
I’m glad he had so much confidence in me. So I brainstormed. The filling was almost there, and besides, it’s easy to tweak a filling. The main issue was the texture and flavor of the chocolate coating. How can I both boost the flavor and make it creamier? The additional challenge was that I was making these peanut butter cups non-dairy.
First idea: Use a praline-filled chocolate bar, such as Rosemarie Schmerling, for extra nutty flavor. (If this brand if not available near you, any good quality Swiss praline-filled bar would work.)
Then it hit me: why don’t I add peanut butter to the chocolate too? That wouldn’t only add flavor, but it would also give the chocolate a creamier texture.
Boom. We nailed it.
- ⅓ cup creamy peanut butter
- 3 ounces sweetened peanuts (such as peanut crunch or honey roasted peanuts)
- 2 tablespoons confectioners’ sugar
- 2 tablespoons oil
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
- pinch kosher or sea salt
- 3 (3.5 ounce) Rosemarie pareve chocolate bars
- 3 heaping tablespoons peanut butter
- Prepare the filling. Combine all ingredients in a blender and blend until smooth. Add to a piping bag.
- In a bowl, combine chopped chocolate and peanut butter. Melt in microwave on 30 second intervals, stirring in between. Add to a piping bag.
- Line up mini cupcake wrappers on a baking sheet. Pipe some chocolate into each wrapper. Then pipe in some peanut butter filling. Then top the filling with more chocolate. Shake the whole tray so the tops flatten. Let set in fridge or freezer. Store in freezer.
Totally perfect
Is there an error in the ingredient amount of the chocolate coating? The recipe says 3 chocolate bars and 3 tbs peanut butter, but the directions say 2 chocolate bars and 2 tbs of peanut butter. Please clarify. Thanks.
Hi! Thanks for pointing out. I edited the recipe. I originally made these with 2 + 2 but then I’d have extra filling. So added more coating and now it’s an even match and both get used up at pretty much the same time.
In the end is the chocolate with praline or without? It seems like the steps want it, but ingredients lists doesn’t call for it specifically.
YES. Chocolate with praline.
Looks yummmm. If i do want to make it dairy can i just use dairy chocolate or will it affect texture?
I’m not sure. These taste so dairy I never tried making them actually dairy. It should be fine, but if you make a dairy version, let us know how they came out!
Whenever I (used to/I stopped because we wouldn’t stop eating them!) make peanut butter cups I “paint “ the inside of cupcake liner and too w chocolate (w egg brush etc) so the chocolate is thin and decadent! It’s not so easy but we loved it the best that way!
Oh, When will the Jewish chocolate companies just come out with some good Reese’s imitations already (and not those sketch ones for $3 a peice!!!)
Great tip, but yes, that’s a lot of work! I’ve always heard that this is the ONLY chocolate item that the CY world hasn’t been able to duplicate well (yes, there have been attempts, but none are good). But now you don’t need them because you have a recipe 😉
Around how many peanut butter cups does the recipe make?
It depends on the size of your cupcake wrappers. We got about 40 with the wrappers we used (there’s about half our batch in the photos). But you can get more or less with smaller (yes, there’s extra mini cupcake wrappers available) or larger wrappers.
It says to put in vanilla is that vanilla extract or vanilla sugar?
I only have regular salted peanuts…can I use them? Maybe add maple syrup to sweeten the mixture?
amazing recipe!
I sifted the confectioners sugar and then mixed all filling ingredients with a spoon. much easier then dirtying a blender
thanks for awesome content always!
Yay! Enjoy!