How To Make Caramel Turtles

It’s easy to make turtles. The hardest part will be not eating too many of them

Preparing turtles is quite easy, and fun too. And they are delicious. The crunchy pecans (make sure to toast them first, it makes a HUGE  difference) combined with the gooey caramel and some dark chocolate to bring it all together….so, so good. 

So let’s get to it. 

You will need about a cup of whole pecans, prepared caramel, bittersweet chocolate to melt, and some Maldon sea salt flakes.

First, start with the caramel. 

We used this recipe here. Don’t be scared of caramel, it’s not that hard to prepare. And with this recipe you don’t need any special tools. 

You can prepare the caramel in advance and reheat it briefly in the microwave or on the stovetop to soften it. Don’t heat it for too long or else you will risk that the caramel loses its signature gooeyness and turns hard like a candy. 

Start by toasting the pecans. This step is key to add that finishing taste to your turtles. Heat your dairy oven to 350°F and toast the pecans on a baking sheet for 10 minutes. Let cool.

Prepare the caramel as in this recipe here and like we said, this can be done in advance too.

Lay out the pecans, 4 pecans clustered together.

Top with a dollop of caramel. Use a spoon to do that. 

Push the pecans in so that they stick to the caramel. Let set. 

Melt some bittersweet chocolate and pour over the caramel, to cover. 

Sprinkle with a few flakes of Maldon sea salt

and refrigerate until set.

You can use these turtles to decorate your cheesecake or simply lay them out on a platter for a beautiful and delicious treat.

Homemade Caramel Turtles

Ingredients

Instructions

  • Prepare caramel according to instructions in this post. This can be done in advance, and caramel can be warmed when ready to assemble.
  • Preheat oven to 350°F. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Add pecans and toast for 10 minutes. Let cool.
  • Lay out the pecans, 4 pecans clustered together. Top with a dollop of caramel. Use a spoon to do that. Push the pecans in so that they stick to the caramel. Let set.
  • Melt some bittersweet chocolate and pour over the caramel to cover. Sprinkle with a few flakes of Maldon sea salt and refrigerate until set.
header between carpools logo

Renee Muller

Renee is a sought-after food and lifestyle stylist and the author of two cookbooks. With dishes and linens as her paint palette, it’s her artistry that weaves a beautiful story in the photos on this site.

15 responses to “How To Make Caramel Turtles”

  1. Danielle Avatar
    Danielle

    Hi
    Recipe looks delish. What is the pot in the picture of the caramel? Looks like smooth and easy to clean.

  2. Rochel Avatar
    Rochel

    I love the cheesecake featured! Do you have instructions for that pretty frosting somewhere?

  3. D Avatar
    D

    Omg this is dangerous!
    Just wondering, why don’t you top it with dairy chocolate? Once the caramel is dairy anyway…:)

    1. Mindy Avatar
      Mindy

      May be too sweet. The pareve chocolate will offset it better. Plus the sea salt.

  4. Q Avatar
    Q

    Can I use store bought Caramel? That comes in glass jar. Will consistency work?

    1. Leah Avatar
      Leah

      I’d love to know the answer to this, as well…

    2. D.A. Avatar
      D.A.

      I’d imagine the problem with store bought sauce is that it wouldn’t harden to a candy consistency. When you pick up the turtle, I’m thinking it would probably fall apart.

  5. Chavie Avatar
    Chavie

    I made the caramel turtles but was very disappointed how they tasted! After it sat out for a little the caramel turned lighter and didn’t taste good. Did anyone else have this problem? I’m curious to know what you think might have gone wrong?
    Note to anyone making it; make sure the caramel is cool enough and hardens a little before you put it on the pecans.

  6. Sh Avatar
    Sh

    Tried to make the caramel twice and caramel didnt thicken. After i spooned it between the nuts it slowly spread together. What did i do wrong.

    1. Renee Muller Avatar
      Renee Muller

      I am so sorry you had that experience! Please see below I addressed a few points

  7. Hadassah Avatar
    Hadassah

    I also made the turtles and caramel last week. Firstly the caramel needs to be left out until it hardens a little and is t runny. Secondly, they don’t seem to last well unless stored in the freezer but even so, the caramel didn’t look good on the turtles. Hope u can clarify the recipe

    1. Renee Muller Avatar
      Renee Muller

      Yes, it is best to store them in the fridge/freezer until it’s time to serve or gift. They will be fine at room temperature too but won’t last as long and will start losing their sheen.

  8. Shani Avatar
    Shani

    Thanks for such a great recipe! It was delicious! I found it hard lifting up the titles since the caramel was soft.. I recommend next time placing a little chocolate, caramel and then chocolate on top so that the chocolate hardens under the caramel and the turtles will be easier to handle!
    Thanks again for a great site!

  9. Sima Goldberg Avatar
    Sima Goldberg

    Can Renee comment on these comments?
    I want to make this recipe but would love to know if there are more instructions so the caramel is right consistency and they harden enough to handle.

  10. Renee Muller Avatar
    Renee Muller

    HI! Caramel is temperamental – ideally use a candy thermometer to get the perfect hard texture but still chewy enough to eat. In the recipe we linked in this post we didnt use a thermometer because the caramel was to be used as a sauce that gets warmed up for pouring etc.
    But here is how to get your caramel perfect for this turtle use:
    1- wait until the sugar, water and corn syrup mixture becomes golden/almost amber colored. ONLY then combine with the warmed heavy cream mixture.
    2- once combined, place a candy thermometer inside the pot and cook on medium low for 5-7 minutes until thermometer reaches 248 degrees. Remove from heat. Caramel will harden as it cools so maybe wait a bit before you spoon over the pecans. If caramel hardens too much you can rewarm to soften, either in a pot or in the microwave.
    Hope this helps!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!