The Perfect Go-To Honey Cookies Recipe for Rosh Hashanah

Do you skip making honey cookies for Rosh Hashanah because you don’t love them so much? Well, you’ll love these (and you’ll probably love them all year too).

Remember the honey cookies of your childhood? You know the ones that come in the bag and have just the right soft texture? Well, now you can recreate them!

A few years ago, my neighbor Cipi shared a recipe for honey cookies. Since then, it’s the first thing we make for the Rosh Hashanah season. We make a triple batch for the freezer and pull some out every time we need to make kiddush or a Laishaiv BaSukkah. Bonus is that they defrost really quickly.

Honey cookies on parchment lined cookie sheets.

So when it was time to photograph and share this recipe with all of you, I called Cipi to track down the original source. She remembered that one of her children made these cookies in school and the teacher sent the recipe home with the cookies. The teacher had gotten the recipe from the mother of another student she’d taught. So the trail ran cold at that point. Due diligence was done but we’ll just have to give the credit to Cipi R. And maybe you’ll pass it on to your friends and neighbors and tell them you saw it here on Between Carpools!

Print Recipe
5 from 2 votes

Go-To Honey Cookies

70 medium cookies

Ingredients

  • 4 cups flour
  • 4 eggs
  • ¾ cup honey
  • ¾ cup sugar
  • 1 tsp baking powder
  • 1 tsp baking soda
  • ¾ cup oil
  • 1 tsp cinnamon

Instructions

  • In the bowl of a mixer, combine all ingredients.
  • Refrigerate dough for at least 30 minutes before forming cookies.
  • Meanwhile, preheat oven to 350℉. Roll cookies into balls and place on lined baking sheets. Bake for 15 minutes.
header between carpools logo

Watch us bake these cookies here!

Esti Waldman

Esti’s career has brought her behind the lens of food, fashion, books, and families as a leading photographer. Her talent and technical know-how make the photography you see on the site so appealing.

45 responses to “The Perfect Go-To Honey Cookies Recipe for Rosh Hashanah”

  1. Dinah Avatar
    Dinah

    Tip when working with honey cookies. Keep making your hands wet so they form nice balls. Otherwise they stick to your hands look all messy.
    I have a different honey cookie recipe(heaven!) and find that this top really works

    1. Hannah Avatar
      Hannah

      Would this recipe come out good if I halved it? Also large or extra large eggs?

  2. esta Avatar
    esta

    Could you use white spelt flour for these cookies

    1. chaya Avatar
      chaya

      delicious! i made these ising white spelt flour and a little less sugat. i added extra 1/2 spelt flour aince spelt absorbs water. also i onky used 1/2 cup sugar it came out perfect! tip: instead of rolling balls i used a cookie scoop.

    2. Rachel Spitzer Avatar
      Rachel Spitzer

      I’ve tried it with white spelt flour and I just beefed your add an extra half cup of flour and it came out perfect!!!

      Also tip: I used a mini ice cream scoop and made it wet between cookies and they came out perfectly round and uniform size

  3. suri Avatar
    suri

    use a metal cookie scoop for even cookies, no rolling and no mess!

  4. Esti Avatar
    Esti

    Esta, I’ve made them with white whole wheat flour and you couldn’t tell a difference. Never tried spelt. If you do, let us know how it turns out!

  5. Matty Avatar
    Matty

    Another tip, spray the metal scoop with cooking spray

  6. Sara Iflah Avatar
    Sara Iflah

    Very tasty cookies. Thank you so much for the great recipe. Small tip: Arrange the cookies in a domino-shaped format, so you will bake a larger amount at one time. In addition, to give the cookies the look and taste of real דובשניות, I added the mythological white glaze. It came out very tasty and beautiful. Thanks!

    1. YL Avatar

      Can you share what the white glaze is?

  7. Sara Avatar
    Sara

    heaven! just made them…what memories:-)

  8. Mimi Avatar
    Mimi

    Just made these. Delish

  9. Esther Halpert Avatar
    Esther Halpert

    Can I make the dough and freeze it for when I’m ready to bake them? or should I bake and then freeze them?

  10. Faigy Avatar
    Faigy

    Do you need the dough hook for these?

    1. Hadassah Avatar
      Hadassah

      No. I have just mixed the dough manually in the bowl, worked out great.

  11. Esti Avatar
    Esti

    Esther – I’ve never tried that, but they do freeze very well after baking.

  12. Esti Avatar
    Esti

    Faigy, yes. I use the dough hook in the plastic bowl of my Bosch mixer.

  13. Nechama Avatar
    Nechama

    How many cookies does one recipe make?

  14. Rochy Avatar
    Rochy

    I just made these and they were heaven!

  15. Chavy Avatar
    Chavy

    These are delicious! Just made them! So soft! I use white ww flour and could not tell any difference.
    Thanks!

    1. Hannah Avatar
      Hannah

      Do you use all white whole wheat flour ? Or leave some white flour?

  16. Shevy Avatar
    Shevy

    Just made these. They were delicious. Bake it for the instructed amount and they are light and fluffy. I baked one batch a little longer and they had a really nice crisp.

  17. Chanie Avatar
    Chanie

    Delicious honey cookies! Love that they have no margarine. I used white whole wheat flour too and tastes perfectly fine. I stuck the batter in the freezer for 15-20 mins instead of the fridge because I was short on time and it was very easy to work with. Tip: the cookies grow a lot so leave a decent amount of space between them.

  18. Chaya Avatar
    Chaya

    Would the consistency be the same if I use coconut oil?

  19. Yl Avatar
    Yl

    This is the best recipe I’ve tried so many this is a Winner I just keep making them doesn’t have to wait for Rosh hashana

    1. Estie Avatar
      Estie

      Hi. Just made the batter. It’s more of a batter than a dough…. right? Quite sticky so unsure how to form balls.

  20. Tova Avatar
    Tova

    How many cookies does this yield?

    1. Leah Schapira Avatar
      Leah Schapira

      about 70 medium size cookies.

  21. AILUY Avatar
    AILUY

    My family likes cookies/desserts that are not too sweet. Should I reduce honey and sugar amounts? Thank you

  22. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    What size balls do you make?

  23. Adina Avatar
    Adina

    We made these cookies tonight and they’re a winner! 23 walnut sized balls per cookie sheet (x4!) and baked 12-13 mins. They might all disappear before YT! Consider yourself warned 😛

  24. Rachel Avatar
    Rachel

    Just made these cookies and came out delicious! I added some lemon zest to them to neutralize the egg taste. Such a great and easy recipe. 10/10 recommend

  25. Rivkah Avatar
    Rivkah

    I’ve used this recipe for a couple of years. I found it originally on Aish.com by Elizabeth Kurtz…

  26. Steph Avatar
    Steph

    Hello, i want to make these with the children at my childcare centre but we are an egg free centre, am I able to use egg substitute or will it simply not work?
    Thank you,
    Steph

  27. Miriam Avatar
    Miriam

    Can I make the dough by hand?

  28. r Avatar
    r

    I made these cookies they are delicious!

  29. Rachel Avatar
    Rachel

    I made the dough by hand, absolutely delicious, have made a second batch already. Thank you

    1. Miriam Avatar
      Miriam

      Thanks!

  30. anonymous Avatar
    anonymous

    Hi just made these cookies and they came out delicious. I used Spelt flour and organic sugar and it was great.

  31. Katz Avatar
    Katz

    Hi can I halve the recipe?

  32. BeantheBaker Avatar
    BeantheBaker

    Hi, I just made a 1/2 batch of these for relatives who celebrate Rosh Hashanah. I made the recipe verbatim; no substitutions, which is what I always do when trying a new recipe. I’m a very experienced baker. I would say these are “okay”, but just okay. Fine for this holiday purpose, but I would not make them again as a basic cookie in my repertoire. They are soft and chewy; but I felt they lack flavor. Honey is very subtle, and the relatively small amount of cinnamon really doesn’t add much. Heed others’ warning that the dough (which really is a thick batter) is very sticky. The colder the easier it will be to work with and I also endorse dampening your hands periodically. That said, it doesn’t really matter if you drop these into soft circles as opposed to rolling into balls. They will bake up into a relative round shape and although they do spread, it isn’t that much. Also, watch the bake time: check them at 12-13 minutes. In my opinion, 15 minutes is a bit too long and the bottoms will brown too much.

  33. Lisa Avatar
    Lisa

    Tasty but not quite excellent. They never flattened out. Mine remained fairly round.. I made them for my students as an easy way of sharing a holiday tradition in a classroom setting (dipping apples in honey would be too messy) and they all liked them, but I wouldn’t substitute these for my family’s favorite “Majestic and Moist” honey cake (Smitten Kitchen variation). I made the recipe as written with two very small changes — no baking soda on hand so I subbed more baking powder (I’m an experienced baker so I know the ratios) and I didn’t have cinnamon so I used a smaller amount of garam masala (that wouldn’t have affected the cookies’ ability to spread out).

  34. RAchel Avatar
    RAchel

    5 stars
    This is the BEST honey cookie recipe I’ve ever tried!! I constantly give it to friends and relatives. Just waning them that it’s sticky and not to add flour. Guess the stickiness causes the softness. Delicious!

  35. Chavi S Avatar
    Chavi S

    5 stars
    So easy and so tasty! I always read comments before trying a recipe. Made with white spelt flour, added an extra cup as suggested and only used half a cup of sugar. Wouldn’t know the difference, it still tasted sweet! Added a cinnamon-vanilla glaze which topped the cookie! Made 70 perfect round cookies – loved by all!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!