What If My Simcha Looks Empty?

Are you worried that people won’t be at your simcha? Feel like you don’t have such big social circles. You’re not alone–and you don’t have less friends than anyone else. Here’s why other simchas look “full.”

Editor’s Note: A friend told us about this letter which originally appeared in Mishpacha Magazine and it is reprinted with permission here. Although the letter mentions winter, this topic is relevant for so many of us at any time. Even when not making a simcha, it’s a common sentiment by so many. It’s reassuring to hear that we’re really in the same boat as anyone. Feel free to leave comments at the end to share your feedback and experiences. 

Q: I am making a simcha in a few weeks and I’m dreading it. Of course I’m very happy for my son (the bar mitzvah boy) but I know the kiddush at shul is going to be very hard for me personally. This is because my husband davens at a small shul and I have a very small circle of friends and family, meaning it is going to be a very small affair. Moreover, we’re in the thick of winter where I live and I know that some of the people who are invited won’t show up if it’s a cold or snowy day. In addition, I have a daughter who will soon start dating and I’m worrying in advance that her new husband’s side of the family will be enormous AND bring an entire stadium of friends and community members to the wedding while I’ll scrounge to find twenty warm bodies of my own! I’m mortified in advance! And I have younger kids too, so I’m going to have to endure all this again. Do you have any suggestions that can help me cope?

__________________

The “small-simcha-crowd” experience happens regularly for many of the reasons you’ve already noted. A small shul naturally means fewer people will be at the kiddush. A cold or rainy day certainly reduces those who will trudge over from their homes or other shuls. Sometimes the season of a particular simcha means that a lot of people will be away (Pesach, summer or winter vacations, etc.). And your small social circle is also a very common factor in the creation of a small simcha. But here’s an interesting fact  – your friend circle is about the same size as everyone else’s! Research shows that people everywhere only have 2 – 5 really good friends, with 2 being more common than 5. You are not short on friends; you’re only short on simcha attendees. So who are all those other people at other peoples’ simchas?

In tight knit communities they may be neighbors or shul members – not friends that one speaks to regularly, but people one shares a street or institution with. Sometimes it’s people one shares a history with – classmates or people from a community one used to live in. Depending on one’s lifestyle, including what one does all day, one may have more or fewer friendly relationships with other people. For example, a woman who is the principal of the local high school may have hundreds of acquaintances pouring into her simchas – staff members, parents of students and students themselves. However a woman who works part-time doing administrative work in the same school office, may have only a couple of her colleagues come as guests. And a woman who works primarily in her kitchen in the privacy of her home and who spends her days tending to the many needs of her growing family, may have only her budgie bird to invite! Similarly, a woman who is married to a man who is heavily involved in community matters may be swamped with simcha attendees whereas a woman whose husband works from home during the day and learns with his single chavrusa in the evenings may not be a rich source of willing celebrants. 

In your situation, the shul, your neighborhood, your spouse, the size of your extended family and your own lifestyle have left you with a diminished pool of acquaintances. The small turnout at your upcoming simcha will not prove that you’re unpopular; it will only prove that your daily life isn’t filled with community contact. Nonetheless, you are feeling judged, assuming that others will conclude that you aren’t well-liked. And you might be right about that. You aren’t the only one who thinks that someone can actually have hundreds of friends. There’s no way to stop people from thinking their thoughts, but there IS a way for YOU to stop thinking your own thoughts. Ask yourself if you think you are a good person living a good life. Ask yourself if you want to get a prominent job within the community so that you’ll have more people to invite to your simchas. Ask yourself if you want to start a community initiative of some kind so that you’ll have more people to invite to your simchas. In other words, you can choose to build a larger network of acquaintances in order to solve your simcha dilemma. Or, you can choose to acknowledge you like the life you have and that life comes with a small crowd of “followers.” Once you decide how you want to proceed, you don’t have to think about what others will think anymore.

FOR EXCLUSIVE CONTENT AND A PEEK BEHIND THE SCENES, MAKE SURE TO JOIN OUR WHATSAPP STATUS HERE. JOIN OUR WHATSAPP GROUP AND WE’LL LET YOU KNOW WHEN A NEW POST IS UP!

Sara Chana Radcliffe

Sarah Chana Radcliffe is a psychologist in full time private practice in Toronto Canada, counseling parents, couples and individuals. Mrs. Radcliffe is the author of “Raise Your Kids without Raising Your Voice”, “The Fear Fix,” “Make Yourself at Home,” “Harmony at Home”, “Better Behavior Now!”, “No More Tics!”, and other books on Jewish family life and emotional well-being. Sarah Chana writes a weekly column for the Family First section of Mishpacha Magazine. In conjunction with Jewish Workshops, she has produced an extensive library of webinar classes on parenting, marriage, anxiety and stress management, and she runs a live, ongoing weekly family-life webinar series called “The Family Circle.” Mrs. Radcliffe heads the Sarah Chana Radcliffe Academy where she trains and certifies parenting coaches internationally. She also provides daily tools for parenting, family life and emotional well-being on social media, as well as through her “Daily Parenting Posts” Email List, available worldwide.

To join Sarah Chana for her FREE, LIVE webinar: The Rejection Wound: Healing What Hurts Most click here.

11 responses to “What If My Simcha Looks Empty?”

  1. hudi Avatar
    hudi

    I have a suggestion: make sure to make an effort to attend other people’s simchos! It’s very appreciated and hopefully they will in turn make the extra effort to attend yours for example going out in bad weather or busy time of year etc.. if you are a no show for others don’t expect others to come to yours

    1. Leah Avatar
      Leah

      so true! when came close to the time of my first simcha i started trying harder to go to other ppls simchas even wen it was difficult, out of fear that i should have ppl at mine! BH i had a full house, but now i try even harder because i see that every attendee really makes a difference to the baal simcha!

  2. Sari Avatar
    Sari

    Great article!! I can relate to the writer and it’s a great response. Thank you! It’s comforting to hear that I’m not the only one without 15 friends… 🙂 now I feel better that bH I do have 2 close friends.

  3. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    Can we have an article on how to make a good friend when married with a few kids? I mostly lost touch with my high school friends and do have neighbors whom I go visit on shabbos sometimes to shmooze with, but no one close.

    1. Bassy Avatar
      Bassy

      I feel you! I’ve made really close friends at a shiur I attend. It sounds crazy as a mother of a growing family (and sometimes it IS crazy) but it’s the best thing I do for myself. Once a week I get to spend time with a group of ladies I really love, use my head a bit and get an inspirational boost for the week. The style of the shiur is open to give and take so we all get to enjoy each other. Is there something like this you can try in your neighborhood. It won’t be easy at first and it won’t feel so great right away- the camaraderie builds up over time. I assume any community initiative would provide the same opportunity.

      1. Anonymous Avatar
        Anonymous

        Thanks so much for your reply. I will definitely look around.
        Btw anyone reading this article, having a full simcha does not necessarily mean someone has a lot of friends. My last simcha was BH full because we are close with a lot of family and my husband is well connected, but I personally wish I could have a close friend or two.

        1. eg Avatar
          eg

          Adding to what Bassy said above–there is an org called Link Up (under Penimi.org) where you can actually organize a learning group for your neighborhood. Check the site for contact info. Someone did this in my neighborhood and if I have to point to my closest friends, it’s those ladies at the learning group! And of course, meeting every other week and discussing higher-level things than recipes or carpool (which is great to discuss also, just nice to get a be more elevated once in a while) gives me such a boost. If you are looking for a close friend nearby, this is a really good place to start.
          Other ideas–volunteer for your kids school PTA/ladies auxiliary (I know it’s hard to find time) or for neighborhood causes like the shul n’shei. Being in contact with people regularly is how you make friends. Talking a few times a month about other things generally lends to building a personal connection.
          –a mother with kah a bunch of kids who has some adult-made close friends 🙂

  4. Miriam Avatar
    Miriam

    LOL
    I am the talkative type who has no problem sharing my life with my friends and neighbors, and they in turn share theirs. I have accumulated lots of close friends like this.
    B’H, I do have a lot of attendees at my simchas like this, but you have to willing to be a bit (or more!) socially off 😉

    And I live in a community with apartment buildings. We overlap a lot more with our neighbors, and it enables a tight knit community. If you have an actual house with actual privacy, its harder to make close friends.

  5. Sara Avatar
    Sara

    I must admit this article really surprised me. I had no idea people worried about having an empty venue at their simcha. But if an entire article was written about it, it seems to be a more widespread phenomenon than I thought.
    Honestly, it feels like people are a bit disconnected from their own reality. Everyone has their own unique circle of family and friends, and there’s absolutely nothing wrong with a smaller one. We just need to stay grounded and stop stressing over what others will think or say. Focus on the true joy of the occasion—center your love and attention on the Bar Mitzvah boy, the bride, or the groom, and just celebrate.

  6. Leah C Avatar
    Leah C

    Thanks for the article. I do not have family in town so I don’t have siblings who can come to my simchos. My older son’s Bar Mitzvah was the first week of the summer a few years ago, and I can probably count how many people came, because it wasn’t as full. I remember feeling bad, but it was probably becasue of the time of year. One of my neigbors called me erev Shabbos to wish me Mazel tov and to tell me she will be away for Shabbos, so she won’t be able to come. I thought that was such a sweet gesture, so that is an idea to do for someone else. My second’s son was in the beginning of the school year and was packed! I also agree that it is nice to go to another person’s simcha. I went to my neighbor’s simcha at a shul on the other side of town. She so appreciated that I made the walk in.

  7. Rivka Avatar
    Rivka

    Thank you for this article. It is an even worse feeling when you invite so many people and only a handful show up. That is what happened at my wedding and I still have very negative feelings about it. I never watched my wedding video. Please everyone, if someone invites you that is not well connected or rich, try to attend their simchos.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!