Help Me BCP! How Can I Make a Perfect Coffee Slushie at Home?

You can be drinking a cold, refreshing blended iced coffee slushie in about 90 seconds.

 

In Dairy Made Easy, I included a recipe for a Blended Coffee Frappe, but the texture is more like a blended coffee, not like the icy slushie that I buy at the bagel store. At the time, I was making cold brew coffee avidly, so I always had cold strong coffee ready to blend. But when I don’t have cold brew on hand, I find it incredibly annoying to have to brew coffee and wait for it to cool before blending (hot coffee simply does not work when making a cold drink).

If you look online for coffee slush or frappuccino recipes, there’s a few problems with them. They either contain lots of high calorie ingredients (condensed cream? hello? For a morning coffee? Those drinks sounds more like dessert.) or they take way too long to prepare (are you freezing coffee ice cubes the night before just so you can have your coffee slushie in the morning? I think not). Others required freezing a whole pitcher of coffee, then defrosting and blending it. No.

Help Me BCP! How Can I Make a Perfect Coffee Slushie at Home? You can be drinking a cold, refreshing blended iced coffee in about 90 seconds.

I wanted our coffee slushie to have to following criteria:

  1. Include the normal coffee ingredients.
  2. Be low-cal for every day, although can be made richer by using sugar and whole milk for those who choose.
  3. Can be made in an instant. No waiting. No advance prep. You want coffee? Boom, you have it.

Here’s my new creamy coffee slushie. The only added ingredient is the sugar-free pudding powder; just a teeny bit is the secret to the creamy consistency. The cornstarch in the pudding powder keeps the ingredients together so they don’t separate (how annoying is it when you’re left with flavorless ice at the end?). You can use regular pudding powder if you don’t want sugar free.

Help Me BCP! How Can I Make a Perfect Coffee Slushie at Home? You can be drinking a cold, refreshing blended iced coffee in about 90 seconds.

4.7 from 6 reviews
Coffee Slushie
 
Ingredients
  • 1 cup milk
  • 1 ½ teaspoons good quality instant coffee (I use Nescafe Classico)
  • 2 cups ice
  • 2 packets sweetener or 2 teaspoons sugar, or to taste
  • 1 tablespoon sugar-free vanilla pudding powder
Instructions
  1. Add milk and instant coffee to a blender. Add ice, sweetener, and pudding powder.
  2. Blend to combine. Enjoy immediately!

 

 

Victoria Dwek

Victoria is the best-selling author of nine kosher cookbooks and a popular columnist for Ami Magazine. She always has the words for bringing everything that’s in our hearts onto the page. 

39 responses to “Help Me BCP! How Can I Make a Perfect Coffee Slushie at Home?”

  1. YR Avatar
    YR

    Yum! Looks so delicious and refreshing! The pudding powder needed is the regular one or the instant?

    1. Victoria Dwek Avatar
      Victoria Dwek

      Instant, since that dissolves well with cold.

      1. Bina Kay Avatar
        Bina Kay

        Wish it would clarify in the recipe that it’s instant pudding powder, less confusion for all of us. TY!!

  2. Dinah Avatar
    Dinah

    Thank you!!! I cannot wait to try this!!!

  3. suri Avatar
    suri

    Miriam Pascal actually uses pudding powder in her skinny frapp on her site. I’ve been making it since then. Try vanilla flavored coffee with vanilla pudding if you like vanilla. But I’m more of a mocha flavored girl so I use Colombian coffee with choc pudding powder! Love it!!

    1. Victoria Dwek Avatar
      Victoria Dwek

      Lol, I’m a vanilla girl, but chocolate twist is a good idea for those who like chocolate. I’ve been using pudding powder in my coffee and shakes since before Passover Made Easy. In a supermarket by me, there’s a kosher brand that sells Pistachio Flavored pudding (also sugar-free), and we make yummy pistachio shakes with just milk, ice, and powder! Great low-cal ice cream-shake like treat.

    2. Robin Avatar
      Robin

      I LOVE Mocha!

  4. baila rochel Avatar
    baila rochel

    This was amazing amazing amazing!! Thanks for inventing this for me! I told my 12 year old son that I emailed a recipe developer to make the perfect ice coffee for him and he felt like a million dollars!

  5. zc Avatar
    zc

    Where do I get sugar free pudding powder? Local grocery should carry it?

    1. Victoria Dwek Avatar
      Victoria Dwek

      Yup, regular ingredient, usually in the baking aisle along with the jello.

  6. Dinah Avatar
    Dinah

    Just checked in my grocery and they didn’t have sugar free pudding… ????

  7. cs Avatar
    cs

    Fantastic!!

  8. brandy Avatar
    brandy

    Thanks for this awesome recipe!! What a great cost effective treat!

  9. rivky Avatar
    rivky

    I’ve made this numerous times every day since this recipe was posted! Delicious and so easy!! Guess I’ll just have to get used to me blender being constantly out on my counter

  10. cs Avatar
    cs

    I made it too! Heaven!

  11. Riki Avatar
    Riki

    made this morn and really tastes like the real thing if not better! thank you!

  12. tova Avatar
    tova

    Would this work with soy or almond milk instead of dairy?

    1. Victoria Dwek Avatar
      Victoria Dwek

      See below, yes of course!

  13. Rivky Avatar
    Rivky

    I was wondering like Tova asked if you find this works well with non-dairy milk – I know the pudding box says might not be the same.
    Also, any recommendations for a budger blender that really can crush ice well?
    thanks!

    1. Victoria Dwek Avatar
      Victoria Dwek

      In response to both, yes, nondairy milk is fine if that’s what you prefer! I personally like soy with my coffee too. It doesn’t matter what the pudding box says because you’re not using that for it’s intended use.

  14. Dinah Avatar
    Dinah

    Does anyone know of a grocery or supermarket in Lakewood that sells choc instant sugar free pudding? I got the vanilla diet one which does have some carbs and it was delish but I’m a chocolate gal and would love to make it next in that flavor! Made it 3x already

  15. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    Wow. This shlushie recipe looks amazing! Can’t wait to try it. Question: Does the instant coffee have to be dissolved in water before adding to the other ingredients?

    1. D Avatar
      D

      no u can just put it straight into the blender along with the rest of the ingredients

  16. Beth Avatar
    Beth

    Hi Victoria, maybe you can help me. I’m still looking for a low cal smoothie that doesn’t have bananas but has Greek yoguinsteD of milk. Tysm!! Keep up the Gr8 work!!!

    1. Fh Avatar
      Fh

      Do i need to use the putting?

      1. Sarri Avatar
        Sarri

        I’m in Israel and I’m not sure about the availability of pudding powder. Certainly not the sugar free version. Could I just add a certain amoiunt of cornstarch for the binding effect?

        1. T Avatar
          T

          I am always buying the Osem brand of instant pudding here in the USA, I am sure they have it in Isreal too…

  17. Devorah pollak Avatar
    Devorah pollak

    I made this weight watchers friendly for 3 points! Take a vanilla premier protein shake and use that instead of the milk. I also skipped the sugar. I added a little more coffee to give it a stronger taste! Taste delicious!

    1. Devorah Avatar
      Devorah

      I forgot to add that I used the sugar free jello

  18. Devora Avatar
    Devora

    If I want to make these for shalach manos, has anyone made this and frozen it and then defrosted it somewhat? Or should I just make it the morning of. I don’t have many shalach manos I need to give out, but I would like to do it in advance if it could work…

    1. Goldie Avatar
      Goldie

      Was wondering if vanilla sugar or vanilla extract can be used instead of pudding, or does the pudding give it a certain texture too?

  19. Rachel Lermer Avatar
    Rachel Lermer

    Hi! Can these be made in advance and frozen? Thinking about sending as shaloch manos! Tysm!

    1. Victoria Dwek Avatar
      Victoria Dwek

      I’m sorry, I don’t have experience making them ahead! 🙁

  20. C Avatar
    C

    Incredible! Tastes like the stores if you add more sugar!

  21. Chaya Avatar
    Chaya

    can i skip instant pudding?
    i dont regularly buy and want to make this recipe…

    1. Victoria Dwek Avatar
      Victoria Dwek

      No. There may be other recipes out there that call for different ingredients.

  22. Malka mandel Avatar
    Malka mandel

    Do you dissolve the coffee in water? Did anyone try making this in advance and freezing?

    1. Malka Mandel Avatar
      Malka Mandel

      Does the coffee get dissolved first?

  23. Rachel Avatar
    Rachel

    When making the pistachio version – how much pudding powder should i use since I am not adding in the instant coffee?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!