Baking Your Rosh Hashanah Challah? These Are the Best Crumbs for Your Challah + More You Need to Know

The kids are in school, and we can finally clear our heads a bit to prepare for Yom Tov. First on the list? The best challah of the year. 

Even if you’re not the type to prep ahead, Rosh Hashanah isn’t so far away. If we can get that challah and a couple of desserts into the freezer this week, we’ll have a much calmer time next week when it’s crunch time.
Let’s start with that challah. Here are 4 things you need to know for Rosh Hashanah challah your family will ask you for all year.

  • The Right Flour

Avid challah bakers promise that the right type of flour makes all the difference for the fluffiest challos. The best flour you can get for challah is this High Gluten Flour by Dependable Foods. It’s the best quality flour there is on the market. In stores, in comes conveniently in both 5 lb and 6 lb bags, so it’ll work for you no matter which recipe you use. You can also get it in bulk and have it on hand always with your Dependable Foods order. 

  • The Crumbs

Even if you use your own challah recipe, you need to use these crumbs (complete recipe below) to top your challah (it’s such a treat!). In a bowl, knead together 1 ½ cups flour, 1 ½ cups sugar, and 1 stick of margarine (it should be at room temperature and soft). Top all your challahs generously!

  • The Challah Recipe

We first shared the sweet challah recipe below by Mrs. Goldy Siegfried four years ago. This challah will make you think that you’re eating fresh, heavenly sweet rolls and you’ll be hooked. It’s the perfect sweet way to start your Rosh Hashanah meal. 

  • The Braid

Learn how to braid a round challah as you see here in this video: How to Braid Round Challah.

5.0 from 2 reviews
Sweet and Fluffy Challah
 
Serves: 6 challahs
Ingredients
  • 4 ½ cups of warm water, add as much needed
  • 2 cups sugar
  • ¼ cup active dry yeast
  • 3 extra large eggs
  • ½ cup oil
  • 2 tablespoons salt
  • 5 pounds flour
Topping:
  • egg, for egg wash
Crumbs:
  • 1½ cups flour
  • 1½ cups sugar
  • 1 stick (½ cup) margarine
Instructions
  1. Prepare the crumbs. Combine flour, sugar, and margarine. Mix to form coarse crumbs. Set aside.
  2. Begin by using 4 cups of warm water (3 cups cold water from the sink and 1 cup boiling water). Combine water, yeast, and sugar in the bowl of an electric mixer. Stir and let sit 6-7 minutes.
  3. Add eggs and oil. Add salt and ⅓ of the flour, mix for a few seconds, until combined. Add another ⅓ flour, and mix just until combined, then the last ⅓ of the flour. Add remaining water (or just as much as needed for a nice sticky dough). Mix for 10 minutes on high speed.
  4. Remove dough from mixer and place in a large mixing bowl. Smear the top of the dough with a little oil. Cover and let rise 2 hours.
  5. Right before you are ready to braid the challah, preheat oven to 200ºF. When it reaches that temperature, shut the oven off.
  6. Divide dough into 6 parts. Braid and place in pans. Place braided challah into the warm oven and let rise an additional 1 hour (otherwise you cover and let rise on the counter until it doubles in size, 1 to 1 ½ hours).
  7. Preheat oven to 350ºF.
  8. Brush challah with beaten egg and place crumbs on top. Bake until challah is golden. Challah with crumbs needs to bake a little longer than usual challah.

Between Carpools

Between Carpools is a collaboration between five talented friends who like to get a lot of stuff done “between carpools.” Since 2016, we’ve been sharing home and organizing tips, parenting insights, activities, how-to’s and DIYs, and of course, entertaining ideas, recipes, and inspiring reads both on the site and app.

13 responses to “Baking Your Rosh Hashanah Challah? These Are the Best Crumbs for Your Challah + More You Need to Know”

  1. Dara Avatar
    Dara

    How would this do without the eggs? Or using a flax egg sub?

    1. Malka Avatar
      Malka

      My secret tip to heavenly sweet challah is after you place the crumb on the challah, lightly sprinkle the tops with a bit of vanilla sugar.
      I’ve had several neighbors walk by and smells my challah in the oven and ask if I was making fresh doughnuts!

  2. Chamy Avatar
    Chamy

    Does the margarine in the crumbs make a huge a difference or can we sub. with oil?

    1. Leah Schapira Avatar
      Leah Schapira

      You can use any crumb recipe. Usually those with oil have egg in the mixture too.

    2. Es Avatar
      Es

      I substitute oil. Comes out perfect. Sometimes I add a tbls vanilla sugar. Absolutely heaven!

  3. Jen Avatar
    Jen

    Do you add the whole 2 cups of sugar when proofing yeast? Also, is it ok to add salt
    To the yeast mixture? I’ve always heard to keep them apart.
    Thanks

  4. Melissa Avatar
    Melissa

    I want to bake now and freeze. Should I make and bake the challah with crumb topping and freeze or freeze the dough not baked ?

    1. Chamy Avatar
      Chamy

      People have a lot of success freezing raw dough. But it never worked for me! I rather bake and freeze and defrost fully before warming up for a short amount of time so that I don’t re-bake the challah.

  5. Chamy Avatar
    Chamy

    I just wanted to report back that this was one of the most amazing sweet challahs we’ve ever had!! I followed the recipe down to every last detail and it definitely paid off! Thank you for sharing!

  6. Chevs Avatar
    Chevs

    Heaven!!!

  7. Rebecca Avatar
    Rebecca

    Looks amazing but Sephardic people be aware that the beracha for this challah will be mezonot since it is sweet.

  8. Elisheva Avatar
    Elisheva

    Will this recipe work by hand if I don’t have a strong enough mixer to make the dough in?

  9. Michele Avatar
    Michele

    Can I make this by hand?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!