The Top Between Carpools Recipes of 2025

These are the ones you clicked and cooked the most!

Which are the top Between Carpools that you might have missed? 

On this list are not only our newest recipes–it’s simply the recipes that get the most views over the course of the year. 

It’s the new, popular recipes– plus the old favorites that you keep going back to, again and again! When a recipe makes the list for consecutive years in a row, we know it’s a bonafide favorite. 

See the top 20 most clicked and most cooked recipes of 2025 right here. 

For Past Top Recipes

Top Recipes of 2024
Top Recipes of 2023
Top Recipes of 2022
Top recipes of 2021

#1

Sticky Honey-Garlic Pargiyot

This recipe by Vera Newman looks too good not to try.

#2

The 9×13 Life: Classic Chicken with Rice 

Any complete dinner that works in a 9×13 is going to be popular, no doubt!

#3

​​The 9×13 Life: One Pan Chicken Poppers

A top recipe for three years running! And it’s no doubt. They’re the quickest, easiest way to serve poppers ever.

#4

Healthy Chewy Muffin Squares

The new take-to-school breakfast solution.

#5

Mike’s Chicken

Whether you bake or fry, whether you serve them during the week or for Shabbos, whether you prep fresh or stock up and freeze–these are a favorite all around for the second year running.

#6

Pareve No-Mixer Cinnamon Buns

This is new for 2025 and the easiest-to-prep cinnamon buns-from-scratch.

#7

Sushi Rice in the Oven

Once we nixed the pot, there was no turning back. You’ve all been turning here to make sushi rice in the oven for three years straight.

#8

Tastes like Fried Corn Flake Schnitzel

We shared a Dinner Done 2 favorite with you right here.

#9

Rice Krispies Chocolate Chip Cookies

A kid-favorite with great texture.

Oven Baked Schnitzel

#10

Eti’s Oven Baked Schnitzel

You’ve been baking and loving this dinner staple for five years straight.

#11

9×13 Meatballs

Even though these were first published a few years back, they rose in popularity recently this year.

Meatballs

#12

Baked French Onion Rice

We’re always looking for easy 9×13 sides, and this delicious rice takes only five minutes to assemble!

#13

Crispy Sesame Chicken Stir Fry

Authentic and extraordinary.

#14

Oven-Smoked Brisket for Pesach

Everyone’s favorite brisket. No need for fancy ingredients. Just a few basics, and it’s amazing all year round.

#15

Oven Mock Matbucha

It freezes well, and there’s no stirring over the pot. This is quickly becoming the top Shabbos dip.

9x13 biscotti

#16

Chocolate Chip Sticks

A classic since 2019! In Dinner Done 2, we changed them up to enjoy a cookie stick with a softer consistency. It’s hard to decide which ones we love more.

#17

Best Meat Pizza with Pastrami and Facon

When you love a recipe for two years running, we know it’s a keeper.

#18

Sheet Pan Chicken Sandwiches

If we discovered this recipe just a few days earlier, it would have made it into Dinner Done 2. It’s a delicious dinner solution.

#19

Honey Garlic Confit Chicken

Last year’s #1 favorite still makes it to the top 20!

The Pesach Pancakes That Everyone Loves. They’re healthy. They’re tasty. And even your toddler will eat them.

#20

Pesach Pancakes

Lots of you click on these every single morning of Chol Hamoed. We know we do.

Between Carpools

Between Carpools is a collaboration between five talented friends who like to get a lot of stuff done “between carpools.” Since 2016, we’ve been sharing home and organizing tips, parenting insights, activities, how-to’s and DIYs, and of course, entertaining ideas, recipes, and inspiring reads both on the site and app.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!