Sliced baked Navel Pastrami and brown sugar/mustard sauce over it, on a cutting board. Knife and extra sauce in condiment dish.

Sweet and Tangy Pastrami

With just two ingredients and a hands-off cooking method, this pastrami couldn’t be an easier main course.

The total package! It’s economical as far as meat is concerned, features just two ingredients (plus the meat), and is super crowd-pleasing. I got this recipe from a friend years ago and I can’t begin to tell you how many people it’s been shared with. It’s become a favorite staple in so many homes.

There’s no specific time when you can prepare and serve this. You can cook it all day and serve it during the week or save it for Friday night .

I haven’t tried it in a Crock-Pot if you want to serve it Shabbos day, but who knows, that might work! If you make it during the week, you can wrap it up and add it to your cholent once it’s already cooked.

Navel Pastrami that comes in the vacuum-sealed bag

Ok, let’s make this. It couldn’t be simpler. You’ll want to choose the Navel Pastrami that comes in the vacuum-sealed bag.

The Navel Pastrami that comes in a vacuum-sealed bag is fatty and pre-cooked. You can also find stores that cut a large roast into chunks if you don’t want such a large piece. This recipe works with those smaller chunks too! 

In a small pot, combine the brown sugar and mustard. (Editor’s Note: We also tried simply combining the brown sugar and mustard in a bowl, without cooking in the pot, and pouring it over. We found that the results were similar.)

boiled brown sugar and mustard poured over a Navel Pastrami in a foil pan

Remove the pastrami from the bag and place in a 9×13-inch pan. Pour sauce on top. 

Sliced baked Navel Pastrami and brown sugar/mustard sauce over it, on a cutting board. Knife and extra sauce in condiment dish.

This will cook low and slow for 6-8 hours, but when it’s done, just slice it up into chunks and serve with the sauce!

That looks good!

Sliced baked Navel Pastrami and brown sugar/mustard sauce over it, in a foil pan

It freezes well too! Just cover it tightly and freeze in the sauce. Remove from freezer and warm up (covered tightly) in oven. This can sit in the oven on a low temperature for a long time. 

Sliced baked Navel Pastrami and brown sugar/mustard sauce over it, on a cutting board. Extra sauce in condiment dish.

Keep that extra sauce for serving on the side (why not?)

Sliced baked Navel Pastrami and brown sugar/mustard sauce over it, on a cutting board. Knife and extra sauce in condiment dish.
Print Recipe
5 from 1 vote

Sweet and Tangy Pastrami

Ingredients

  • 3-5 lbs Navel Pastrami in a vacuum bag
  • 1 cup brown sugar
  • 1 cup yellow mustard

Instructions

  • Preheat oven to 225°F.
  • In a small pot, combine brown sugar and mustard. Bring to a boil and mix. Pour over pastrami.
  • Remove naval pastrami from bag. Pour sauce on top. Cover very tightly and bake for 6-8 hrs.
  • This freezes well. Slice and freeze in the sauce. Remove from freezer and warm up (covered tightly) in oven. This can sit in the oven on a low temperature for a long time. 
header between carpools logo

Naomi Elberg

After moving to Michigan with her family back in 2011, Naomi unpacked her stand mixer, started baking, and hasn’t stopped since. She specializes in gourmet challahs, babkas, and seasonal goodies for all dietary needs including vegan, gluten-free, and various allergies. She can be contacted via instagram @naomi_tgis.

11 responses to “Sweet and Tangy Pastrami”

  1. Ruchama Avatar
    Ruchama

    Looks amazing! Any options for those of us that don’t have the “heart” to eat navel pastrami? Can it work with another cut of pastrami roast? Thank you!

  2. B.A. Avatar
    B.A.

    Looks really good! Plan on trying it…
    Please can you come up with a Kosher LePesach option, to bake navel pastrami with a mustard free sauce.
    Thanks!!

  3. Bevy Baida Avatar
    Bevy Baida

    Bake it at what temperature?

  4. K Avatar

    Does it have to specifically be navel??

  5. Yael Shapira Avatar
    Yael Shapira

    Will this work with something like London Broil or other roast types?

  6. Msl Avatar
    Msl

    Can I use corned beef? And pour the sauce on top before serving?

    1. Avi Feldman Avatar
      Avi Feldman

      5 stars
      I make this recipe with corned beef on the regular and it’s delicious.

    2. Pamela Katz Avatar
      Pamela Katz

      Hi! I just wanted to know why I need a precooked pastrami if I am going to cook it anyways for 6 hours. I also wanted to know please at what temperature to bake? Thank you

  7. Esti Avatar
    Esti

    Any mustard free sauces?

  8. Rochelle Avatar
    Rochelle

    If I make a much smaller piece half or quarter the amount of pastrami how long should I bake it for then?
    Thanks

  9. Layla Avatar
    Layla

    Is the pastrami supposed to be frozen or thawed ?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!