Pomegranate Ice Cream

Elevate the flavors of ice cream with this perfect-for-Rosh Hashanah easy to prep ice cream dessert.

Before the days of Between Carpools, I used to share my original recipes in Mishpacha and Ami magazines and any adapted recipes I shared (with permission) on my food website called cookkosher.com. 

A few years ago, cookkosher kept crashing. The technology was so outdated, it couldn’t keep the site consistently live. To get it back up would be a complicated process–and was it worth it? By then, Between Carpools was already popular and the home of all our newest, favorite recipes.

And so, sadly, I announced to the cookkosher cooks that the site was going to close. I asked all the readers to save their favorite recipes because they would soon not be accessible. The next time the site would crash, we would say goodbye and all the recipes would be gone. Over the years I’ve gotten a few requests for specific recipes and sadly, most of the time, I didn’t personally have the recipe anymore. 

Pouring pomegranate juice into Braun food processor with frozen strawberries.

One recipe I DID save was a Pomegranate Ice Cream I had shared In 2012. It was a slight adaptation of Faigy Grossman’s and Chavi Feldman’s recipe. That recipe became a staple on my mother’s Rosh Hashanah menu and so whenever anyone asked me for it, I was able to say, “Yes! I have it” and send them the recipe.

in Braun food processor bowl

But why keep a good recipe to myself and those who remembered it? Many of you may already have this recipe, but many of you most likely do not. And the combination of strawberries, pomegranate, and ice cream is so good!

This ice cream comes together quickly…after you blend the strawberries and pomegranate juice,

in the bowl of Braun food processor

add the ice cream. 

blending in a food processor

A food processor makes it quick and easy.

spooning ice cream in to silicone molds

Then, it can be placed in silicone molds

leveling ice cream spooned in to silicone molds

and leveled (we used an offset spatula).

Homemade ice cream back into the vanilla ice cream carton

Or just put it into a container for scooping later. 

Removing ice cream from their silicone molds

If you’re using silicone molds, see how easy it is to make this an elegant dessert?

Reading the original recipe, I laughed when I read the last line, “Garnish with fresh pomegranate seeds and serve. During the summer when pomegranates aren’t in season, I garnish it with blueberries.”

Today in New Jersey where I live, you can find pomegranate seeds all year round. While I’m grateful that I can find lots of things all year round, there is something about eating fruits in season and when you can’t it keeps you more creative. 

I love recipes that have less than 5 ingredients. With so few ingredients you know it will be quick and easy, and there’s less room to make a mistake. Aside from the ease factor, the additions to the ice cream will add so much flavor; even if you’re using non-dairy ice cream. 

Print Recipe
5 from 3 votes

Pomegranate Ice Cream

Recipe adapted from Faigy Grossman and Chavie Feldman.

Ingredients

  • 16 oz bag frozen strawberries
  • cup confectioners’ sugar
  • 1 ¼ cups pomegranate juice
  • 56 oz vanilla ice cream, slightly defrosted

Instructions

  • 1. In a blender or food processor, combine frozen strawberries, confectioners’ sugar, and pomegranate juice.
  • 2. Add the defrosted ice cream and blend until combined. You can mix the ice cream with the blended fruit by hand to create an ice cream with swirls, however we prefer it mixed in completely. 
  • 3. Pour the mixed ice cream into the original container. You don’t even have to wash it out. Freeze until firm. Or place the ice cream into silicone molds.
  • Garnish with fresh pomegranate seeds or blueberries and serve.
header between carpools logo

Leah Schapira

Leah is the best-selling author of 10 kosher cookbooks. She’s known as a master “connector,” bringing people together and collaborations to life.

 

23 responses to “Pomegranate Ice Cream”

  1. Sharona Avatar
    Sharona

    I have this recipe from cook kosher days!
    It’s our family fave!!!!
    I Already made for Yom tov.
    But love the mold idea – do you think I can reblend and freeze into molds now?
    Or will ruin the taste?

    1. HK Avatar
      HK

      Hey! Have the same question. Did you try defrosting it and putting it into molds?

  2. Leah Avatar
    Leah

    Yay!! So happy to have this recipe again! This is the ONE recipe I missed from cookkosher and thought that I would sadly have to live without it! Thanks for sharing!!

  3. Rivka Avatar
    Rivka

    Doesn’t balabusta choice also have a Pom ice cream recipe? Is it the same?

    1. Ruchy Avatar
      Ruchy

      Yes I’m pretty sure it’s this recipe! We love it here!

  4. Shulamis Weil Avatar
    Shulamis Weil

    Link for molds or what size are they? Also what is it garnished with – mint leaf?

    1. Between Carpools Avatar

      We added the mold to the post. Yes, mint leaf.

  5. Dorit Avatar
    Dorit

    Do you have an easy homemade ice cream recipe to recommend?
    It’s hard to find pareve vanilla ice cream where I live.

    1. SS Avatar
      SS

      Easy vanilla ice cream recipe
      4 eggs
      16oz whipping cream
      1/2 c sugar
      1 tsp vanilla

      Beat egg whites until stiff, add sugar and beat until stiff again, add whipping cream and beat until stiff a third time. While the mixer is still on add the yolks one at a time and vanilla, mix until incorporated. Freeze.

  6. Lenora Avatar
    Lenora

    Any recommendations for a good parve ice cream?

    1. Between Carpools Avatar

      We like abe’s Parvelicious.

    2. Shaindy Avatar
      Shaindy

      Many national chain groceries sell Breyers Non Dairy Icecream. Itused to be made with almond milk but now ismade with oat milk and it is super creamy and delicious. Also much cheaper than most Jewish brands. Note that the hechsher is Chof-K DE so you have to be okay with that. I was told by my posek that it is okay to eat after a fleishig meal (Just not directly with fleishig) but ask your own LOR.

  7. Henya Avatar
    Henya

    would these be good as pops on stick or is the texture too soft?

  8. Sara Schwartz Avatar
    Sara Schwartz

    Which pomegranate juice is recommended?

  9. rachel Avatar
    rachel

    5 stars
    you can look at old recipes with archive.org see here: https://web.archive.org/web/20180129090751/http://www.cookkosher.com/

  10. chaya Avatar
    chaya

    hi
    I was actually looking for a recipe from you and could not find it, and tried replicating to the best of my ability. I wonder if you can give me that recipe. It was for a sweet potato feta salad. I remember it was romaine, scallions, mushrooms, sweet potatoes and feta. Is there a way I can possibly get that recipe?

  11. F Avatar
    F

    How do I ensure the molds don’t get freezer burnt?

  12. M Avatar
    M

    How does the mixture fit back into the 56oz container with all the added volume?

  13. Leah Goldman Avatar
    Leah Goldman

    M that is a very true comment how would it fit in the 56 oz container. another question you give a recipe for parve ice cream but it only makes 26 oz is that enough for this pomegranate ice cream or does it have to be 56 oz

  14. Leah Avatar
    Leah

    AMAZING AMAZING AMAZING!!!
    BCP did it again!
    Thank you for the most scrumptious dessert!

  15. eg Avatar
    eg

    5 stars
    Delicious! I halved the recipe to make sure we’d like it before making the whole thing but I would def make it again after tasting it… Easy and yum. I froze in individual plastic disposable dessert cups even though the molds look much prettier. Maybe one day I’d invest in them. Looking forward to serving on yt!

  16. Rivkah Avatar
    Rivkah

    5 stars
    Just made a smaller amount of this using so delicious coconut vanilla vegan ice cream! Needed to feed a vegan so couldn’t go with the egg containing parave brands. Used a 500ml container ice cream, 1.5 tbs confectioners sugar, about 1/4 of the bag of strawberries, and 3/8 cup pomegranate juice. The coconut flavor adds such a nice twist! Really yummy!!!! (Fit super nicely into my silicone egg cup mold which I’m using to freeze individual portions, 7 total with a little left over for me to nosh on 🙂 )

  17. Sk Avatar
    Sk

    Has anyone tired this with cranberry juice? Would that work?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!