Savory Onion and Garlic Brisket

9x13 life bcp

Have you been searching for that savory roast without loads of sugar? Slow cook this Onion and Garlic Brisket.

Editors Note: When it come to brisket, with all the rises in meat prices over the last couple years, there’s been one holdout. It’s that second cut brisket. It’s still a good quality cut of meat at a great value.

We always prefer the second cut over the first cut. The first cut tends to be dry, but the second cut is always nice and tender when cooked right. 

We tend to give brisket a lot of love on Between Carpools. There’s this Oven Smoked Brisket; it’s a Pesach version of our Dinner Done Oven Smoked Brisket that we actually make all year round. There’s also a great Crock-Pot Brisket option (great if you don’t keep an oven on). There’s this Tried-and-True Beer Braised Brisket and this Silan Brisket.

Do you want a savory version instead without the sugar? This recipe is from Chavy Breuer who prefers her meat that way. She tells us,

“For years, like everyone else, I made the standard meat recipes with ketchup, brown sugar, honey and all the regulars. 

Then, one time, while at a restaurant, I realized “Wow, the meat is so good.” And I realized that I was tasting the actual meat — restaurant meat is not typically loaded with sugary sauces. So I started cooking meats with just fresh ingredients and spices.” 

The slow cooking method also yields that soft, super tender meat. 

Pearl onions in the bottom of a baking pan. Rubbing brisket with oil and seasoning on parchment paper.

There’s instructions on an easier way to peel the pearl onions in this post.

Brisket + pearl onions, garlic cloves, oil and seasoning in a baking pan ready for the oven

This recipe calls for salt-free seasoning. Lots of different companies make versions of it, including Trader Joe’s, Lawry’s, and Mrs Dash. It’s optional if you don’t have it, no worries.

Here it is–meat, perhaps the way it was meant to be. We still do love our sugary briskets, but we really enjoyed this one too!

Print Recipe
5 from 4 votes

Savory Onion and Garlic Brisket

Ingredients

  • 3-4 lb 2nd cut brisket
  • 2 tbsp oil
  • 1 8-ounce bag pearl onions, peeled
  • 16 garlic cloves
  • fresh thyme and rosemary, optional but reccomended!

Rub:

  • 1 tbsp kosher salt
  • 1 tbsp black pepper
  • 1 tbsp garlic powder
  • 1 tbsp onion powder
  • 1 ½ tbsp paprika
  • 1 tsp dry mustard
  • 1 tsp salt-free herb seasoning, optional

Instructions

  • Preheat oven to 250°F.
  • In a roasting pan, place half the onions and garlic. If adding rosemary and thyme add some under the roast here as well.
  • Place the brisket on top and rub with half of the oil and half of the seasoning. Flip it over and repeat with remaining oil and seasoning.
  • Top with remaining onions and garlic and fresh herbs, if desired.
  • Cover and bake for 6 hours.
header between carpools logo



Chavy Breuer

23 responses to “Savory Onion and Garlic Brisket”

  1. lP Avatar
    lP

    This looks amazing! Can it be made with a delmanico roast instead of brisket?

    Also, does this freeze well for yt?

  2. Chavy Avatar
    Chavy

    Yes, it freezes well. It is a basic rub, so you can substitute it with any meat.

  3. HK Avatar
    HK

    Just what I was waiting for!!!
    Always on the lookout for divine meat recipes using basic ingredients – the more wine, garlic & onions – the better!

  4. Amanda Rosenfelt Avatar
    Amanda Rosenfelt

    No liquid for the meat?

    1. CB Avatar
      CB

      No. It forms its own liquid while cooking.

  5. Brocha Avatar
    Brocha

    Can it be baked on 200?

  6. devora Avatar
    devora

    Can different onions be used if we cant find pearl onions? I don’t know if Israel has that

    1. Chani Avatar
      Chani

      I was wondering the same thing. I’d probably just use regular onions

    2. miri Avatar
      miri

      for sure you can use either diced or sliced onion

  7. Toby Avatar
    Toby

    5 stars
    This was delicious and eaten till the last drop. A good change from all the sweet sauces…

  8. Yocheved Avatar
    Yocheved

    I made this for yom tov and everyone LOVED it! I had one kid who in between meals told me that he’s so excited for a few hours from now because he’s gonna get meat again 🙂 My new go to recipe! such a hit!! (and i used regular onions cut up)

  9. Chanie s Avatar
    Chanie s

    Can’t wait to make this . Do you blend the sauce after baking or leave the whole garlic cloves ?

  10. Rivky Avatar
    Rivky

    Can I make this in a crock pot?

  11. Pg Avatar
    Pg

    5 stars
    Delicious! We had on Rosh Hashona and I’m making again for Sukkos.

  12. Suri Avatar
    Suri

    Very delicious! For the next time I make this, I would put less black pepper since it had a very peppery taste.

  13. Faigy Avatar
    Faigy

    I used less black pepper than listed in the recipe and it was still a bit too much. Great recipe but definitely needs way less pepper. Even for pepper likers like us
    I also used regular diced onions because my nearby stores didn’t have pearl onions and it was just fine!
    I used a hand/stick blender to blend the sauce after it was done cooking and it made a delicious thick gravy.

  14. S.B. Avatar
    S.B.

    Re: Pearl Onions, in New York supermarkets (kosher and otherwise), you can likely find peeled pearl onions in the section of the frozen vegetables. (Bird’s Eye Brand).

  15. Tzippy Avatar
    Tzippy

    How can i tweak this recipe for pesach?

  16. Hadassa Avatar
    Hadassa

    I baked for 6 hours on 250 as the recipe indicated and it came out really really tough. Not soft at all. What could I have done wrong ? There was a lot of liquid (melted fat?)
    .

  17. shira Avatar
    shira

    Does this freeze well?

  18. Racheli Avatar
    Racheli

    I spiced it myself based on our preferences, I didn’t use fresh garlic because I didn’t have, and I used a regular onion julienned. It came out AMAZING, it was polished off until the last drop.

  19. Miriam Avatar
    Miriam

    5 stars
    Amazing recipe! We loved it- from my mother in law to my husband to my 6 year old daughter, and everyone in between! This will be my new go-to recipe!

  20. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    5 stars
    Incredible recipe! I’ve made it many times and it’s always a bit. I use regular sliced/diced onions and put less pepper than the recipe calls for.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!