Crunchy Crackling Baby Red Potatoes

These crispy and tender roasted potatoes will be your go-to potato recipe from now on. It’s simply the best technique for perfect results.

Editor’s Note: Naomi has shared a few great recipes here on BCP, starting with her famous Sufganiot. We also loved this fun Lava Cake and the ever popular Sweet and Tangy Pastrami (also great for Chanukah!). Naomi is also the source for lots of great challah tips, including how to adjust your dough for humid days, how much challah dough belongs in each pan, and can challah dough be made in advance?

We heard these potatoes, a recipe of Naomi’s, were so good too! So we asked her to share!

Baby red potatoes in a pot of boiling water.

Since we’re always trying to simplify things we tried testing it out and seeing if we can skip the boiling stage. We’re sorry to say, but no. It’s not the same. These must be boiled first. (One quick shortcut that’s almost as good, is to place the potatoes, sliced, in a bowl. Cover with boiling water and let sit.)

So follow Naomi’s instructions and you’ll be rewarded with crunchy, cracking potatoes!

Now, let Naomi tell you about these:

Consider yourself warned: Once you pop, you can’t stop Crunchy Crackling Baby Red Potatoes

So basic. So simple. So tasty. So addictive!

I’ve never met a potato I didn’t like (sweet potatoes are a whole other story). These potatoes are the ultimate trifecta…crunchy, flavorful, and can be easily doubled and tripled (because 1 batch is never enough)

Baby red potatoes in a mesh strainer on a tea towel. Spice mixture in a glass bowl, wooden spoon nearby. Oil in a Pyrex measuring cup.

The trick is the boiling. It gives the potatoes that soft inside, allowing the outside to get crispy quicker.

Mixing all the other ingredients in a bowl with a wooden spoon.

Once they’re boiled, combine all the other ingredients in a bowl and mix.

Slicing boiled potatoes in half over a glass bowl and adding them to the mixture in the bowl.

By now, your potatoes should be cool enough to handle. Slice and add to the mixture.

Coating the sliced potatoes in the mixture - with gloved hands.

Get them nicely coated!

Placing coated halved red potatoes, cut side down, on a parchment lined baking sheet.

Now, you’re finally at that roasting stage. Add them to your REAL baking sheet, cut side down. 

Flipping baked red potatoes on a parchment lined baking sheet.

Now you see why these are special. This is going to be your favorite go-to potato from now on. 

Baked red potatoes on a parchment lined baking sheet.

It’s exactly the way you want them to be….perfectly crisp on the outside, soft and tender on the inside.

Print Recipe
5 from 2 votes

Crunchy Crackling Baby Red Potatoes

Ingredients

  • 3 lbs baby red potatoes (2 bags Trader Joe's)
  • 1 heaping tsp sweet paprika
  • 1 ½ tsp kosher salt (add more or less to your preference)
  • 4 tbsp dry parsley flakes
  • 5 garlic cloves; crushed or 5 frozen cubes
  • 1 heaping tbsp mayonnaise
  • ½ cup oil

Instructions

  • Boil potatoes until fork tender in salted water.
  • Carefully drain. Cool completely, and then cut in half.
  • Meanwhile, preheat oven to 375°F.
  • Line a REAL metal baking sheet with parchment paper.
  • In a large bowl, mix together spices, garlic, mayonnaise, and oil.
  • Add potatoes and toss to coat. Transfer potatoes, cut side down, onto a baking sheet and bake for 25-30 mins. Turn potatoes over (they should be nice and roasted by now) and continue to bake until desired doneness. You can keep the potatoes cut side down longer if you want them darker and crispier.
header between carpools logo

Naomi Elberg

After moving to Michigan with her family back in 2011, Naomi unpacked her stand mixer, started baking, and hasn’t stopped since. She specializes in gourmet challahs, babkas, and seasonal goodies for all dietary needs including vegan, gluten-free, and various allergies. She can be contacted via instagram @naomi_tgis.

16 responses to “Crunchy Crackling Baby Red Potatoes”

  1. Elisheva Avatar
    Elisheva

    How well do these reheat?

    1. Rayzee Avatar
      Rayzee

      also wondering about that…

    2. Chaya Goldstein Avatar
      Chaya Goldstein

      Yes they reheat amazing. 350 uncovered. I make them on Thurs for erev shabbos and I reheat them on Friday it’s delicious

  2. Devoiry Avatar
    Devoiry

    Can I prepare this a night before to bake the next day?

  3. Dena Avatar
    Dena

    5 stars
    DEE-LIK-UOUS!!

  4. YH Avatar
    YH

    You can boil in a 9×13 pan and then poke holes on bottom to drain in sink 🙂

    1. RS Avatar
      RS

      You’re my kind of cook! Thanks for this idea!!

  5. Sara H Avatar
    Sara H

    I made these last night and they were perfect!! They had that soft creamy inside which is the best part of baby potatoes and a great crisp on the outside! Will definitely make these again, thanks for sharing this recipe!!

  6. Miriam Avatar
    Miriam

    Can I make them with Trader Joe’s mini sweet potatoes

  7. BR Avatar
    BR

    5 stars
    Absolutely delicious!
    I used regular baby potatoes instead of red because that’s what I had at home and they went down so well! A winner recipe!

  8. Mrs. S Avatar
    Mrs. S

    I love that this recipe looks delish with no msg involved!
    How does one wash potatoes to properly rid them of possible bugs issues?

    1. G.S. Avatar
      G.S.

      I can’t find any kashrus website that says there is a specific procedure for bugs. I just scrub with a veggies brush if I’m keeping the peel on, some people soak and rinse. I am no Rabbi, so do your own research ofc!
      https://www.star-k.org/articles/wp-content/uploads/bugchecking.pdf

  9. Chaya goldstein Avatar
    Chaya goldstein

    I have been making them for a while now as an erev shabbos dish instead of kugel and they are delicious.
    Lately I have been adding acorn squash and it’s insanely good!
    I take 1 acorn squash and wash it really well, cut it into half and then into slices (like moon shaped ) and I throw it into the bowl with the potatoes and toss.
    Bake same as you would potatoes ( I do it on the same tray on top of the potatoes) and it becomes this soft and crispy delicious squash – even my kids love! P.s. no need to double the mixture. Enjoy!

  10. Tzipory bayer Avatar
    Tzipory bayer

    Delicious potatoes!
    I used half red potatoes and half regular Idaho potatoes, was really good with Idaho potatoes as well!
    Make sure to make enough because this was sort of a snack before dinner as well.

  11. Miri Avatar
    Miri

    Any alternative to using mayonnaise?

  12. Jmr Avatar
    Jmr

    If you make this before Shabbos, are they still crunchy or do I need to serve right away?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!