The 9×13 Life: Penne Alla Vodka

No, this is not a gummy/mushy 9×13 pasta. This is real, good, authentic penne alla vodka, with no pot needed. Make it with vodka sauce and heavy cream (or you can use Tuscanini Vodka Sauce and make it on a whim!).

9x13 life bcp

We admit, when we received this email from Leah Kletski sharing her technique for 9×13 penne alla vodka, we were a little skeptical. 

Sure, we love anything 9×13 just as much as the rest of you. They save the day so often. This 9×13 Baked Ziti was one of our earliest 9×13 recipes and it practically started a revolution (right after these all-time favorite 9×13 Oatmeal Squares). 

They’re absolutely perfect for when you’re short on hands-on time, but have just a couple moments around 90 minutes before dinnertime to toss things together and pop it in the oven. In Dinner Done 2, you’ll find another pasta favorite in a 9×13 version: Stuffed Shells.

If there’s one drawback, though, like One-Pot Pastas, these types of pastas, while great when served fresh, tend to turn mushy if left sitting.

Leah’s technique, though, changes that. We’re not sure why the texture of this pasta turns out just like pasta prepared in a pot, but the bottom line is, you will not need any pots or any dishes at all the prepare this delicious penne and receive rave reviews.

Adding penne pasta to a 9x13-inch aluminum foil pan.

Begin by adding one pound of penne to a 9×13-inch baking pan. 

Adding water to penne pasta in a 9x13-inch aluminum foil pan.

Cover with water. For us, this was 5 cups. Cover well and bake at 350°F for 30 minutes.

Using its foil cover and a towel, draining pasta water from a 9x13-inch aluminum foil pan into the kitchen sink.

Remove from oven, and using the foil cover to help you, drain out the water as best as you can. You will not need a strainer. At this point, the pasta will seem al dente. 

Adding marinara sauce to cooked pasta in a 9x13-inch aluminum foil pan.

Add marinara sauce. Renee chose this gourmet version which is “piecey” but I find that the kids prefer the smooth non-piecey Gefen Vodka Sauce. 

Pouring heavy cream over marinara sauce and pasta in a 9x13-inch aluminum foil pan.

Then add heavy cream and salt. 

Cooked penne + marinara sauce, heavy cream and salt, in a 9x13-inch aluminum foil pan.

Mix well and cover again!

9x13 Penne Alla Vodka

Return to oven and bake for an additional 35-45 minutes. Note that we only tested this in a disposable; baking time may be different if using a real 9×13 (although that would defeat the purpose, wouldn’t it?).

Pouring Tuscanini Vodka Sauce over cooked penne pasta in a 9x13-inch aluminum foil pan.

Cooking Instructions with Tuscanini Vodka Sauce!
Here’s an even better solution if you need to make 9×13 Penne Alla Vodka and you don’t usually have heavy cream available. Keep a container of Tuscanini Vodka Sauce on hand. We first introduced you to this revolutionary summer-saving product in this post (shelf stable and deliciously dairy and authentic!). 

The jar seems small, but it will cover a whole pound of pasta! Note! Cooking instructions are different when using the Tuscanini Vodka Sauce. Bake pasta with 5 cups of water covered for 45 minutes. Drain (it’s ok to leave a bit of the pasta water on the bottom). Then, add the sauce and salt and mix. Optionally, cover and return to oven for just 5 minutes to warm up the sauce. 

Enjoy! You can use the same hack with any of the Tuscanini Sauces if you prefer!

Top view of a portion of 9x13 Penne Alla Vodka in a bowl and its aluminum foil pan.

There you go. Creamy, perfect penne that’s as good (or better) than the restaurant, as simple and easy to prep as can be, and not one bit “gummy” or “mushy.” We’re not sure we’d ever be inclined to take out a pot again!

Print Recipe
5 from 4 votes

9×13 Penne Alla Voda

Ingredients

  • 1 lb penne pasta
  • 5 cups water
  • 1 (24 oz) jar vodka or “vodka style” marinara sauce
  • 12 oz heavy cream
  • 2-3 tsp salt

Instructions

  • Preheat oven to 350°F.
  • Add pasta to a 9×13-inch aluminum baking pan. Cover with water. Cover well with foil and bake for 30 minutes.
  • Remove pan from oven and drain water as much as you can. It is not necessary to use a colander; simply pour water into the sink using the foil to help you keep the pasta from falling out.
  • Toss with vodka sauce, heavy cream, and 2 tsp salt. Cover and bake an additional 45 minutes. Uncover, season with remaining salt (or to taste) and enjoy.
header between carpools logo

FOR EXCLUSIVE CONTENT AND A PEEK BEHIND THE SCENES, MAKE SURE TO JOIN OUR WHATSAPP STATUS HERE. JOIN OUR WHATSAPP GROUP AND WE’LL LET YOU KNOW WHEN A NEW POST IS UP!

Between Carpools

Between Carpools is a collaboration between five talented friends who like to get a lot of stuff done “between carpools.” Since 2016, we’ve been sharing home and organizing tips, parenting insights, activities, how-to’s and DIYs, and of course, entertaining ideas, recipes, and inspiring reads both on the site and app.

18 responses to “The 9×13 Life: Penne Alla Vodka”

  1. Hg Avatar
    Hg

    Boiling water?

    1. Devorah G Avatar
      Devorah G

      Have the same question- does it make a difference if the water is hot or cold when putting it over the pasta before baking? I know in the grain recipes you have specified that it should be hot water before putting in the oven…

  2. R.R. Avatar
    R.R.

    Love this! can the tin be lined with parchment first?

  3. T Avatar
    T

    i think it doesn’t get mushy because you’re essentially cooking the pasta and then pouring off the ‘starchy’ water – vs other one pot pastas where you’re cooking it fully in the sauce and the ‘starch’ stays…

  4. B Avatar
    B

    Can the ziti recipe be cooked this way to, and only then should the sauce and cheese be added?
    If so, how long should the sauce and cheese bake?

    1. Z Avatar
      Z

      I wanted to ask the same thing!

      My family doesn’t care for the no pot ziti as much (although I still make it in a pinch), because the ziti noodles have a funny texture. I don’t do heavy cream or vodka flavored sauce though.

  5. lilly Avatar
    lilly

    The Carbone pasta sauces (pictured but not mentioned) ARE THE BEST. They are pricey compared to other sauce brands but once you try them once you will be hooked on the flavors. Our Favorite is spicey vodka, but the others are great too.

  6. Miriam L Avatar
    Miriam L

    5 stars
    Yum tuscanini pasta sauces are out of this world! i cant wait to try it!

  7. L Avatar
    L

    Love how we all had the same thought about the ziti. I would try it, and bake it for around a half hour after adding sauce and cheese
    One pan ziti 2.0 lol

  8. Sara Avatar
    Sara

    Did anyone else have this issue?
    After the 30 minutes in the oven with only water, the pasta was mushy and gummy, exactly the opposite of the point of this recipe. I use a standard heimishe brand of penne. Where did I go wrong?

    1. Rochel Stareshefsky Avatar
      Rochel Stareshefsky

      I had the same issue.

  9. Bb Avatar
    Bb

    Anyone tried adding cheese on top?
    Still wondering if it needs boiling water or not

  10. Th Avatar
    Th

    Mine also came out mushy and gummy- and I took it out 10 minutes early. I did use rotini shape-could it be that made a difference?

  11. AB Avatar
    AB

    Do NOT add salt if using Tuscanini sauce!

  12. R Avatar
    R

    Mine came out mushy too 🙁

  13. Rachelli F. Avatar
    Rachelli F.

    5 stars
    Incredible the idea is wonderful! Love it!

  14. Michal Avatar
    Michal

    5 stars
    Came out delicious- like restaurant style!!!! Thank you BCP!!!!

  15. BG Avatar
    BG

    5 stars
    Made this pasta. It came out creamy and delicious!! Was a huuuge hit

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

FREE GIFT!

Close the CTA

Get our BCP Lifepages Planner by signing up to our email list!