The Top 30 Products BCP Readers Loved in 2023

There’s makeup, kitchen tools and gadgets, clothing basics, and some fun surprises. See what you loved this year right here.

There are things we love. And then there are the things that you love even more.

We put a lot of thought into the products that we recommend. So, it’s kinda vindicating when we see so many people enjoying those recommendations!

While there are some perennial favorites (eyeliner, lip masks, and belt bags), and lots of camp stuff (duffels, drawers), it’s fun to see lots of new items making the tops list this year.

See the most popular items of past years:
Top 22 Product BCP Readers Loved in 2022 and Top 20 Products of 2021

#1

Stila All Day Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner

Can you believe that more of you bought eyeliner vs. anything else for the second year in a row? The only item that outsold eyeliner last year was Best of Kosher, and this year it’s back in the #1 spot. It was recommended again this year in this post on The Secrets of Long Lasting Makeup.

view item

#2

Nordicware Big Baking Sheet

When the price went down on this big baking sheet (use all your oven real estate!) we recommended in 2020, we let all of you know.

view item

#3

Rockland Rolling Duffel

The best bang for the buck in camp duffels. The 40-inch size is the way to go. Here’s a little secret: the price is lower in the winter and goes up as summer gets closer. We originally recommended it in this Sleepaway Camp list.

view item

#4

Camp Labels

Camp stuff continues to top the list, and after duffels, labels from Label Land are next.

view item

#5

Brite Brush

A game changer for any mom who struggles to get her kids to brush on their own! Read all about it in this post.

view item

#6

Adidas Tiro Track Pants

It makes sense that these are often bought in bulk come camp season. If you have little boys that are first getting to the Tiro stage, get your education in this post.

view item

#7

Braun 12 Cup Food Processor

Oh, there’s lots and lots of Braun Food Processor love on Between Carpools. It was tops last year and it’s near the top again.

view item

#8

Lululemon Everywhere Belt Bag

Still a teen staple. We featured it in our Graduation Gift Guide.

view item

#9

Nesco Food Dehydrator

We guess you’re making a lot of beef jerky. This machine was recommended in this post featuring our favorite beef jerky recipe.

view item

#10

Jack & Becky Pajamas

The softest, coziest, and our childrens’ perennial favorite. (We hope the winter sale is still ongoing by the time you read this.)

view item

#11

The H&M Sweatshirt

This became the sweatshirt of 2023. Comfy at home, but cute enough to go out with also. Great not-oversized but not-fitted fit. And $14.99. No wonder everyone wants one.

view item

#12

Target Kid’s Puffy Backpack

When we saw that this one ended up being the most popular backpack at the start of the 2023 school year, we realized that our readers have really great taste. It’s so on trend at such a good value! It was highlighted in our backpack roundup here!

view item

#13

Leather Photo Album

It’s hard to come by a classic photo album today!

view item

#14

Gold Series Detangling Milk

This product has been a game changer for girls with curly hair. Read all about it in this post.

view item

#15

Taco Cat Goat Cheese Pizza

Since this is a favorite, whenever it’s discounted a bit come Prime Day or Black Friday, it goes on the deals list. So much fun for the buck.

view item

#16

Hast Knives

It’s our favorite, and we’re glad that you’re enjoying these gorgeous knives that really perform as well! See why we love them over here.

view item

#17

Laneige Lip Mask

Renee discovered this lip mask in 2021 and since them, readers have agreed, it’s their favorite too. Read about it here.

view item

#18

Matte Gold Silverware

Such a good value if you want a set of gold flatware that you don’t have to be worried about ruining! So many of you took advantage.

view item

#19

The Bosch Universal Mixer

There’s either lots of kallahs or lots of women who want to upgrade their challah baking, because everyone wants to grab a great deal on a Bosch. Although our Black Friday deal has long since expired, you can still get a great deal on the basic White Universal Mixer on Amazon here. For the challah bowl or the set with the challah below, head over to Magic Mill.

view item

#20

Phomemo Label Printer

We’re glad you’re enjoying this gadget as much as we are. We first featured it in this post but Phomemo labels pop up in our posts all the time. It’s the ultimate tool for anyone who likes to fill their freezer!

view item

#21

T.O Collection Stretch Pants

Around back-to-school time, you stocked up on your older boy’s favorite everyday dress pants, with the “Flex” being the most popular. Learn more over here.

view item

#22

Walmart Sterilite 3 Drawer Tower

Another camp item! You can pack these drawers into the camp duffel above and still have lots of room for other stuff. They were recommended in this camp post.

view item

#23

J.Crew Factory Boys Long Sleeve Polo

The best school polo for younger boys! Great value and great fit. There’s lots of great colors. He’ll simply look clean and neat. This polo was the most popular in our Polo Shirt roundup published before Back-to-School time.

view item

#24

Fullstar Vegetable Chopper

This is what Renee uses to make her Israeli salad and we all want a gorgeous salad like that too!

view item

#25

Alo Long Sleeve Tee

The #1 favorite workout staple, first featured in this What to Wear When You Workout post.

view item

#26

Banana Republic Forever Sweater

Can’t-go-wrong staple.

view item

#27

H&M Cotton Twin Duvet Cover Set

Such a cute one at a can’t-go-wrong price. Lots of other well-priced kids linen sets that were recommended in the past are no longer available, but this one is!

view item